Enchantix In 2d Or In 3d?, Which one do you prefer? The Enchantix from the show or the movie? Options

[Unica-Musa]

Maybe I didn't like movie because I didn't understand anything because I watched italian version...
Who knows? Maybe I'll change my mind....

[RenaEnchantix]

I like the 3D much more. they're more interesting than the 2D, and it's better animated. Though I love the Winx Club, I always thought the 2D animation was some of the worst i've seen. the Enchantix transformations (excluding Bloom) were better than the rest of the show animation wise, but still a lot of room for improvement. Also, Stella's pigtails forming was so poorly done that it really ruins the whole thing for me (pig tails don't just grow on the sides of your head, they're formed from hair...).

The only thing I didn't like about the 3D ones was that the girls all had their enchantix hair before they were transformed. at the begining of the transformation they had enchantix hair, and it was just weird. at least in the 2D version they showed the hair changing. I did really like how Tecna's hair changed, I kind of wish that was brought into the 3D versions, but I know from experience that would be very hard.

[Unica-Musa]

ok...now I'm still a 2d fan....

[Zhanneel]

The 3D movie was really spectacular, and nicely animated. But don't worry Unica-Musa, I'm still an avid 2D lover too . It's what I grew up on and what I still watch. There have been so many nicely animated 2D series (i.e. Avatar the Last Airbender or any Studio Ghibli film) that I'm still able to praise it even in this 3D world.

This post has been edited by Zhanneel: May 10 2008, 10:01 PM

[winxclub-joy]

ya, I'm a 2D and 3D lover, no worries of comparing these and that =D

[Unica-Musa]

I know movie enchantix is really nice...
I love what they did with Stella

[Hirondelle]

When I first saw that the movie was in 3D, I was highly upset. (I'm another one of those that worships the golden age of animation haha) But from watching the whole thing, it really wasn't that bad. It gave me a new respect for the 3D, I'm actually starting to prefer it over the 2D in this show because they just mess up so much in it and it ruins it for me. I must be OCD or something, but I don't like how in the charmix, each girl has their own speed but it's for the same thing; Tecna doesn't even stop in the beginning, and I don't think Flora really does either, and then it'll show the hip of one of the girls and it takes more than a second for the other piece to appear. That's just one of the instances that I don't like with the show's animation.

Anyway, back on topic haha, I prefer the 3D transformations, only because I find them more fitting to them. It's like they were able to do what they really wanted instead of being limited. What could've made them better though is if they also styled the hair during the transformation , that would've been awesome. They also make really really pretty screencaps. xD

This post has been edited by Hirondelle: Jul 9 2008, 5:48 PM

[humbu111]

i didnt vote, they're both too awesome to pick one
but the movie music is WAY better, no doubt about it
whats funny is that the movie transformations are in the same order as i liked the winx girls before! (now its slightly changed at the end of the order)

[Dilaraphoenix]

2D is better than 3D. Cause it's longer, slower and more detailed(but just the transformation).

[Abby]

I like both, I think it looks a lot more colorful in 3D than in 2D, but they're both still good.

[SolarfireWinx]

I love both! I'm an animation nerd, so I died when I saw the Enchantix forms in 2d....*_* soo...sparkly...XD and then when I heard that they were planning a movie in 3D, I got extremely worried about the quality and how it would look, but I'm so in love with both! ^_^ They all look great!!

[winxclub-joy]

I like both still ^^

[PinkSugar]

It really depends, but overall, I like the drawn out, 2d version better. Of course, I really liked Musa, Tecna, and Aisha/Layla's enchantix in the movie (particularly Layla. At least she was given actions instead of just floating up through the air and holding up her hands.)

I liked the sequences for the most part better in the animation. They were longer/seemed more unique. However, seeing it in 3d was pretty cool. I liked the songs for both, but I'd have to say that I liked the 3d's song better.

[humbu111]

ya, the movie song blows the cartoon ones away, but the 4kids ones did give a sense of "wow" when u heard it with the transformations going on, especially when u watch it for the first time, its amazing!

[Zhanneel]

I still love the 3-D movie animation, but I think I'm leaning back to 2-D as my favorite. I started watching parts of the movie again and I really couldn't stand the animation of Bloom's eye and the way she blinks. It looks so....weird? lol What's wrong with me? xD

[P-girl]

Ah well, it leads to funny moments. *Remembers Bloom's 'Dude, WTH?'-look when fooling around with Livy and Jolly.*

[Zhanneel]

LOL, yes. For a moment I thought she saw through the "fourth wall" and was like "who the heck....?" =P.

[Music123]

Well I think the outfits are prettier in 3D but the transformation is better in 2D in my opinion. The movie isn't out in a language that I understand yet ,so maybye the reason I am not fond of the 3D transformation is because I don't understand the song. I will have to wait and see

[P-girl]

*Raises hand* I can translate the song if you like, at least the Dutch lyrics, and those are known to be 95% the same as the Italian original. (.... That was a grammar cartwheel if I ever saw one.)

[Jahnavi]

Well, I once saw a video on YouTube which had the Enchantix song in English. (And I'm pretty sure it was the official dub.) Anyway, the lyrics went like this:

Enchantix,
Shining fairy powder falling on me,
Magic Enchantix,
My powers will be at the maximum,
I'm invincible,
I'm ready to go!
Magical Enchantix,
It makes me feel so beautiful and strong,
I'll raise my energy,
Finally I'll become a real fairy,
I'm invincible,
I'm ready to go!