Enchantix In 2d Or In 3d?, Which one do you prefer? The Enchantix from the show or the movie? Options

[Jahnavi]

Do you think the Enchantix transformations came out better in 2D (in the show) or in 3D (in the movie)?

Personally, I like the 2D Enchantix transformations, because they were longer and more detailed. Then again, in the movie, all the transformations are roughly of the same length, whereas in the show, Layla's was much shorter than the others'. Layla's not one of my favorite characters, but I think it was unfair that her Enchantix was a good 15 seconds shorter than the others'.

[winxclub-joy]

I like them in both version, no matter what they still look beautiful to me. But the only thing I hate is Bloom's outfit in the 2D version, it should look nice in rainbowish, but.............

[mightymarty2]

to be honest it is very close for me but I am leaning slightly towards the 3D side

[P-girl]

I dunno.... they each have their own pros and cons..... although I'm leaning towards 3D, because they managed to make Bloom's dress actually work. In 2D, I think her dress is butt-ugly (No offence) but in 3D.... I think it's gorgeous for some reason.

[Zhanneel]

Totally on the gate. I really don't know which way to swing =P. My instinct says "NO! 3-D is the bane of all great animation!" and then I look at the quality and I'm like "shut-up self". =P Both are great, but I'll miss the 2-D style now that they are not doing anymore episodes. But, you know, their hair looks freaking fantastic and realistic in the 3-D style, so that helps me cope. Also, their eyes are so realistic and glassy, along with greater detail in facial expressions. I still like both =(.

This post has been edited by Zhanneel: Apr 28 2008, 6:04 PM

[Stevie]

I'd say 3D, it's much better then 2D!

[Abby]

Even though I am not too fond of the 3D faces, I think the outfits are a lot better colored in 3D and are a lot better looking in general.

[Jahnavi]

Yeah, I've noticed that in 3D, their eyes are often out of focus... One is looking downwards, and the other is looking to the side...

I wonder why they didn't just make the movie in 2D...?

[winxclub-joy]

Because to make it realistic, least mistakes. At first I do not like the 3D characters, but after seeing their movie and the process of how they've made it, I gotta admit it that this is the best 3D movie that I've ever seen (Even if there's goofs) They've proof that they've team up, working together to create this great animation. And also, it's hard to create a 3D film, (Like how the disney created toy story, ya they even stayed in the studios for nights to create this show out) and we really can't blame the goofs in 3D film, if you're an animator, you will know why and what they hell is going on in the process.

[Jahnavi]

True, they must have put in a lot of hard work for the 3D animation.

This post has been edited by Jahnavi: May 3 2008, 1:33 PM

[winxclub-joy]

yes they did, and I bet that there is a lot of fight during the process of the show

[Princess Rissa]

kind of both

[Unica-Musa]

I personally love more the 2d version
because thats original winx

[Zhanneel]

Hmm, I think if I'm watching a movie for only a short period of time, I love the 3-D look. However, if I'm watching a cartoon series, I really prefer it to be in 2-D. (like in Code Lyoko, I still like the 2-D segments more than the 3-D parts)

[P-girl]

I personally love more the 2d version
because thats original winx

You kinda sound like a certain type of Transformer fans who think everything past G1 (The very first cartoon) sucks. I don't mind it, it's your opinion and I respect that, but.... life's a lot more fun and filled with less dissapointments when you just open up for new styles and at least try to enjoy them. They're there to stay. You can live with it, you can complain, or you can just go with the flow and try to enjoy them. And really, 3D is not that bad.

[Abdu 6b]

I like 2d better

[winxclub-joy]

Now if I'm not wrong, the animators are trying to create a 4D short cartoon. (I heard it from my teacher) Dead, we got to learn another stuff. If Straffi going to use 4D to create winx club, I'll say........

Let's see first before we made comments

[Unica-Musa]

You kinda sound like a certain type of Transformer fans who think everything past G1 (The very first cartoon) sucks. I don't mind it, it's your opinion and I respect that, but.... life's a lot more fun and filled with less dissapointments when you just open up for new styles and at least try to enjoy them. They're there to stay. You can live with it, you can complain, or you can just go with the flow and try to enjoy them. And really, 3D is not that bad.

I enjoyed in 3d a bit...but bloom is again in the spotlight and that ruined the all movie
no offense bloom fans

[winxclub-joy]

if this season 4 is going to focusing Bloom for no reason, I'm suing Bloom xD

[P-girl]

I enjoyed in 3d a bit...but bloom is again in the spotlight and that ruined the all movie
no offense bloom fans

Uhm, it's been all about Bloom for three seasons and a movie... she's the main character. So it's not really fair to shoot down the movie because of it.