its kind of like the topic "Rate the avatar above you", just with signatures.
rating goes from 1 to 10, 10 being the best, 1 being bad.
9/10. I like the picture. A bit crowded though.
9/10, I love the sparkles, the location of the text, and the pic of flora.
9/10
I like the color's and the tecna images
9/10 (again). I like the effects and the picture that you used but a little too pinkish.
7/10
The design is nice.... I personally don't like that colour of pink.
9/10
I love Palladium hes the best teacher.
Cool Final Fantasy
... 8/10 for *dops* and Palladium fangirl. I like Rikku! I also like those videos in your siggy Palladium fangirl.
Thanks. I love the first one. The music is really nice and it has good anime in it. Mermaid melody and Full Moon wo Saga****e are one of my favorites.
Really cool nice to see a fellow anime fan
Same here. Anyways, 8/10 for your siggy. ^_^
Thanks I also give yours 8/10
i like your videos.. soo 8 1/2 of 10
8/10. I think maybe it could have a different color of font and for the picture of Stella in her dress to be better. Maybe a little more effects but the colors are good.
I still say 9/10 for the top one and the bottom one as well ^_^ I like the brightness of the bottom one
this person doesnt have a pix siggy lolx 10/10
9/10
10/10 perfect score.
8/10
Nicely animated.
9/10 palladium rocks!
8/10. I like the colors.
10/10
8/10 For the first one.
The image is a little unclear, but that's about it, nice job.
9/10 for the second.
That's so sweet.
9 of 10 for first
8 / 10 for second
Umm... 8/10 all to together.
first:
10/10 I love Flora
second:
9/10
I love it, its cute.
9/10
luv that scene when floras dreaming of herself and helia^_^
9/10
9/10
Yes your right, Bloom is cool
9/10
That was a cute scene, altough I think Helia looks a teensy-bit to serious for the occasion, but that's not your fault.
8/10. I bit too busy and grudgy. Palladium is cool though.
10/10 i like flora nice light effects^^
8/10
Nice picture, but a bit plain.
9/10. Love the videos!
all toghether: 9 1/2 of 10
9/10 for the first one
7/10 for the other.
8/10 again. It is a bit too busy and grudgy.
8 out of 10 for both together love the pics
6/10. It is bad quality and not that appealing. I love anime though.
First : 10 / 10
Second : 9 / 10
9/10. It looks great.
10/10
...8/10...
8/10 again lol
9/10
I like the poem and the picures
7.5/10. It is a cute scene. I think Helia should be a little more happy. Lol!
10/10
8.5/10
7.5/10. I like the poem.
20/20 lolx
Lol! 8/10
woo hoo i gotta 8/10 =] lolx
10/10
10/10
Layla's Enchantix looks so cool in green.
thank you 10/10
who made it
Stellaksjuta did.
Still 10/10
wow its nice
10/10
8.5/10. Layla looks nice.
10/10
9/10...It keeps on getting higher everytime I rate it.
10/10
8/10
9/10
Those are some pretty neat outfits! (Altough I think Layla looks like Leia from Star Wars.)
9/10
Nice blending of 2 picture
8.5/10. Good effects.
10-10
9/10. This was my 2000 post!!!!
10/10
9/10
cute with all the girls
10/10
really like it!!
9/10
10-10
10/10
9/10 for the first
10/10 for the second
9/10 for the third.
10/10
10/10
10 out of 10 gorgous
10/10
8.5/10 It is pretty!
9/10
10/10
9 /10 its so sweet!
10/10 Really sweet!
10/10
i like bloom
uhh!! thats cute!!
i would give hmm well 9 1/2 / 10
I love it! its gorgous!!
9/10
I like stella and the picture from Stella with Brandon is cute too
AWW CUTE!
9/10
again 10/10
bloom..
changed my sig^^ new rating plz:
9/10
The dragon! I love the dragon.
i like your siggie, p-girl
i will give 9/10
its cool! and funny and i love palladium!
10/10
still the same,10/10 and 9/10 respectively
9/10 gourgous with all the winx girls
10/10 again! Its really good!
8/10
10/10
9/10
i try some of my sigs and i'll take the one with the best rating
here's my newest creation:
one word cute 10/10
10/10
I like you siggi very much and I love Blooms enchantix I think 10/10
10/10 Cute that its made by *sTELLA*
8/10
8.5/10
It's Mirta.
As a fairy.
Still one of season 3's highlight moments.
9/10
and for serenas 10/10 take this one!! its so cute!
9.5/10
öm you have no signatur 10/10
Nor do you but I give you 10/10 for effort
8/10
8/10
I think I rated yours a lot of times b-loommy.
9/10 mirta rocks!
10/10 for the first and 10/10 for the secend
8/10 ((:
9/10
I like Mirta but I think shes a better witch...
10/10 CUTE
9/10 again^^
(and for *dops*: 10/10!!!!! because its for your brother soo sad!! )
9/10 and 10/10
I like them
10/10
10/10
I love your signature Its very cool
9/10
It's so bittersweet.....
9/10
9/10
I like Blooms enchantix
pretty.
8.5/10
9/10
I like Mirta but she was a better witch
beautiful
10/10
9/10
8/10
8 / 10
its very well done.. but i dont like darkar that much
9/10, I like the one with the screenshots, love the text and the screens. ^_^
9/10
I like the grids overlay.^^
8/10
7.5/10
It's a bit plain.... but the color fits perfectly.
8/10
9/10 for both! they are very pretty!
thnx
9/10 too for both...
i like the texture
9/10, Love how clear the screens are. I also like the color scheme, (how they match each other). Very cool.
8.5/10 its good
7.9/10. Good picture but plain.
aww, it is? (I made her siggy, at the time I had paint).
anyways, 9/10, I like the quality and the lines. It's simple, but for me, too simple.
9/10
7.9/10. It is also kind of plain. I like the circle effect that you used and the other effect.
(Paint must be why it was plain....>_<)
9/10
like the how you did to the grapics with patten line
10/10
9/10
Like I said, 9/10. I like the little bar that says "bloom_sky" that you added. Cute. ^_^
9/10 i like how u make the pattern line
8/10
8/10
first one 10/10
second one 9.5/10
third one 10/10
Very cool brushes and font! 9/10
8/10
Love the color, love the pictures, but it's a bit unclear.
8/10
i rated your's siggy before likes always.
8/10
8/10
10/10
9/10
10/10
8/10
8/10
10/10! XDDD
one word cute!!!
10/10
thnx stellaksjuta.U made it.
okay anime princess your siggy 10/10.amazing.
thanx gurl 10/10
my rating for your siggy is same but fix that userbar below your siggy.it will look more better.
9/10
9/10 too
10/10 i created a new sigi i'm starting to et good at this
8/10
8/10
9/10
8/10 (:
9/10
I like mirta, but she was a better witch...
1st one- 9/10
2nd one- 10/10
9/10
your avvie was better without your name.its just a suggestion.Dont mind if i say that.Sorry.
your siggy 8/10
10/10
9.5/10
9 / 10 for both^^
8.5/10
Nice siggy, maybe a bit unclear because of the color..... Still cool.
(thanks it was my first siggie ever^^)
9, 5 / 10
9/10
I like it very much its cool
your siggy is also good
did u make it ?
9.5/10
hmm 10/10
u know i m gonna always rate that siggy like i did before.
10/10
10/10 yep and i'm always going to rate yours the same
thnx 10/10
10/10
I like your dakar siggi very cool
10/10
I really love you siggy!!!!! its so beautiful!
9/10 fair cute
10/10
10/10 i made myself a new sigi again
Cool
10/10
thanx 10/10 for yours too its cute
I am probably going to be hated on this thread
you start with a score of 10;
A bit too big for my liking -.5
the aqua colored font is a tad hard to read in parts -1
the cut around Bloom and the girl on the right is really choppy -2
should have cut off Bloom's wing on the right, and her hair where it is overlapping the other fairy(It took me a minute to figure out what it was) -1
and this is mostly my preference; but putting a small border on the siggy makes it look a bit more clean and organized -1
lastly; it seems a little cluttered to me. what with the images and then all the text happening. -1
overall: 10-6.5= 3.5/10
I'm really picky when it comes to graphics, its what I do.. ^_^ but I give reason for what I don't like, so if you wanted to improve on those then you know what to try and improve on.
You can be as harsh as you want on me; though I do appreciate feedback and whats not up to snuff
rate my siggy (if you want)
9/10 for both ^_^
7.5/10 its a bit long
10/10
i like how the fade now and the words!!!
thanx 9/10
9/10
i made another one.Howz that
8/10 i have that same pic somewhere
9/10
where
i cant remember where i got it from but i have apic of all the girls in enchantix like that
okay
It's from winx.tk guys. thus the watermark in the middle of the image that says 'winx.tk'
start with 10/10
its GINORMOUS!!!!!!!!!! -3
has a huge watermark to the site its from -1
image taken from a website, without a credit and link back (although the watermark is there....) -2
its not really very exciting..... -.5
10-6.5=
3.5/10
tha!!!!!!!! it is from winx.tk but i find it using google.
it not my fault i didn't give credit to it.
So meru now rate this one plz.
you demanded that I rate it, try to keep in mind, I've gone to school to be a graphic designer, I've been doing this stuff for 8 years; I am picky. critiquing things can be harsh at times, but if you can't handle a truthful critique; then don't ask for one
Darkar (new.....signature)
start with 10/10
too big -2
the font is not really something I like, it looks like it says 'Dankan' -2
no border -1
basically just a screenshot with a grid(boring) -3
sometimes a grid can help in a graphic, when used right. but its just slapped on, and set to the 'overlay' effect. it would help slightly if the grid was erased from over Darkar, so that he was in front of it and not covered. -3
I dont really know what that shiny thing is on the right.... O_O;;;; -.5
@_@ sorrie I ran out of numbers.... I think I went in the negatives lol
meru please note that all my sigis are based on the maximum size alowed for sigis on this site and i might not be one of the best graphics makers here unlike you some people cant afored to go to graphics school, but at lest we try
7/10
Nor can I, I am $7700 in debt to the Bank and I'm not even going to take Graphic design next year if I get into Photography its college kiddies, college. And 99% of what I know I learned over the years myself, I am self taught, but my schooling just confirmed what I believed and taught me a bit more
The size thing is a personal preference, same with borders etc As I've said, I'm being truthfull and saying what I think about signatures. I started out rough; If I had a copy of my first signature I would proudly post it and show you all how bad I was. But its by learning from more experienced people that you learn what to work on fixing, what to do to improve etc. If you get what I am saying....
And I've said in my first post here; I'm not going to be liked in this thread becuase I'm a tough critic but I don't just say "ew thats ugly! 1/10!" I explain what I dislike about it and as nicely as I can I cannot just say "oooh! I love it!!! 100000000/10" just because we are friends I dont work like that
you can be tough on me too, though explainations are appreciated.....
now, hoping that nobody has posted before me after that huge speal Ill rate Anime Princess
start with 10/10
Its a bit too busy -1
choppy cut around Layla sticks out, try taking the eraser tool and set the opacity to 0, then dab away the white stuff... its a start -1
too much words going on, covering the girl in the middle and there are a few words misspelled ^_^;;; -3
borders make a graphic look more neat and organized... -1
a tad too tall for my liking -.5
10-6.5=
3.5/10
7/10
Dont really like that it is on the far right side. and his head is cut of. but like the background.
8/10
I think the colors are a bit to.... Dark yet bright. Yeah, I know that sounds silly.
Can you guys please rate the userbar specifically? Thank you!
sigi 9/10
user bar 10/10
10/10 LOVE IT!
thanx 10.10
7/10
It's a bit off centre....
and it's loneliness.
9/10 for the sigi And 10/10 for the userbar
oops! missed that e xD I knew that too because i checked it just in case on dictionary.com
start with 10
I dont really like the size, but its kind of working for it -.5
the light thingy in the corner is kind of random.... -.5
I like borders, makes sigs look nicer somehow -1
the font is meh, but I can handle it -.5
10-2.5=
7.5/10
CRAP darn you Anime Princess! lol posted before me.
start with 10
image on the left is a little choppy -1
size -.5
I don't like the text placement -1
no border -1
and just that little bit of a watermark on the enchantix image just under her hand, should have either cut or erased it out -1
10-4.5=
5.5/10
And I like my signature on the right side just to be different ... random habit
I'll rate the new one now
10/10
I like it very much its very cool
10/10 its a realy beautiful pic *dops*
7/10
Just asking, are you the one on the left, or the right? Or are they your friends?
i'm the one on the right and the one on the left is my best friend that pic was actualy taken about three years ago i wanted to put my poem a promise of everlasting friendship on it but itsfar too long
oh i almost forgot
9/10 for the sigi And 10/10 for the userbar
9/10 and the userbar 10/10
10/10 and 10/10
I like it
9/10
cool one you got there.
9/10
P-girl
siggy:10/10
banner:9/10
9/10
10/10
9/10
9/10
very cool
8/10 on the first
9/10 on the second
7/10 on the third
10/10 on the userbar but.....
a 5/10 on the total. You're overdoing it a bit.....
as for *Dops*
8/10
9/10
9/10
10/10
9/10
9/10
yes I like them
8/10 on the first
9/10 on the second
7/10 on the third
10/10 on the userbar but...
you say on me p-girl?
I said you're overdoing it. It might sound like nitpicking, but I think you're having to many Signatures.
no matter how much you use i will rate all.
9/10 for all
10/10
nice one 9/10
8/10, cool image, but the text could be better ^_^
Boo
i dont really like the font that says your name; but I like the rest in general
8/10 ^_^
Darkar who made your Bleach sig?
i didn't make it myself i just wrote the text.Got the pic from a friend.
8/10
heh I kind of thought so; It is already a signature, Raxl's to be exact........
10/10, cute and simple.
9/10.i love those tecna pics
9/10 I like the design but I just don't know who's the character
7/10
It's a bit cluttered and unclear.... love the pictures that were used tough.
10/10, great image quality, nice overlay, and cool text. ^_^
userbar- 9/10, never seen the character, but the quality is good...
9/10
Brilliant signature, and somehow, the texture works.
Userbar:
9/10
My turn: Who's that?
The person on my Userbanner is Starscream, an awesome Transformer bad-guy.
The person in my userbar is Tecna ^_^
Well, I stick with my ratings, 10/10, and 9/10. ^_^
I'm thinking of making a new signature, but I don't know if I will just yet.
whatever^_^
siggy 9/10
userbar 9/10
So like i said:
8/10 mostly bcuz it's pretty plain, but I like the pics especially the stella one, where did you get it?
8/10
9/10 i like the background
7/10.
10/10 beautiful
thanx 8/10
Sigg:
10/10
I don't know who the Character is. Perhaps from One Piece or something?
UseBar:
9/10
I really love red. And the text is cool too
8/10 for the animated picture.
9/10 for the poem/lyrics.
The character in Darkar's signature is Ichigo, from the Anime Bleach.
10/10 It's beautifull. I can't make signatures like you can. You're absolutely a master.. XD
10/10 i like animations
10/10 The same I said about your Avvie. I like the Rainbow colors
lol gustav my fav.^_^ 10/10
Ichigo my fav 10/10.
10/10 Beautiful.. The spookycolor makes it cool.
a 8/10
because its Gustav from TH and I dont like them ^.^ but Gustav it better then Tom and Bill so its a 8
Cool siggy.
9/10
9/10
I like your siggi and the pictures from Bloom are very cool
8/10
It's a bit big, but those are some pretty cool Flora pictures.
Avalon one of my favourite characters from winx
9/10
10/10 Like I said before
More gustav. 10/10
Cool.those are my favourite bloom scenes.
10/10
10/10
I like it very much
thnx
my ratings are the same
10/10 ^_^
10/10 Very cool.
Very cool too.
10/10 ^_^
10/10, nice effects on the graphics!
10/10 beautiful! Stella and Layla are cute in your Sigg. ;D
Gustav Football
Cool ^_^ 10/10
10/10....the anime is from Beach right i kinda like it....
10/10 Beautiful. I really like ur pic.
10\10 i really like the text
8/10, I like the pictures and the text, but I personally don't like faded graphics.. Good job though ^_^
9/10
Tecna's Enchantix rocks!
Just a note: Do any off you think that Tecna's Enchantix hairdo kinda looks like a mullet?
8\10 personally i dont like palladium and avalon.
9/10
10\10 i dont know what anime that is but i really like it
7/10
I don't really like the white haze.
uhh again p-girl: 9 / 10
dont change it! its like a status for you.. everytime i see something green: "ahh p-girl wrote something^^"
Cool siggy but who is the girl on the left(you)
9/10
(yeah its me^^)
9/10 to yours.. its cool! but maybe a bit tooo plenty
thnx
10/10
(lol^^ your first vote was 9/10 and now 10/10?? coool )
(now i know its you so i increase your rating by 1)
((ah okee^^ got it^^)
lol that's you anny
9/10
how you make it?
9/10
That is one freaky guy. I love freaks!
its ichigo in all three coloumns.Ichigo in hollow state(evil state)
9/10