Printable Version of Topic

Posted by: sewil101 Apr 30 2007, 9:56 AM

i dont know who i would evict it's too hard evan vow it was my idea , its just realy hard but i guess idont have to choose a winx girl it could be a pixy ,trix, hero,witch or evan someone's parent mabey nuff but he is quite hummerus at times or evan lucy the witch but its up to you!

Posted by: 99RedBalloons Apr 30 2007, 2:31 PM

I would evict Aisha. I'd have said Icy if the Trix didn't absolutely need to be more than two, but as is, I think Aisha is the one to go.

Posted by: *Stella* Apr 30 2007, 3:06 PM

yeah i would evict aisha/layla, too.. from the trix it would be stormy.. and from the specialists it would be nabu i think.. or maybe helia, if nabu isnt in the story, yet...

Posted by: 99RedBalloons Apr 30 2007, 6:39 PM

I would feel bad leaving Flora all alone, though. I kind of like Helia, he seems to have the most dimension of any of the guys; he's the least dully predictable, that is.

Posted by: Connie Apr 30 2007, 10:31 PM

I'm sorry but I have to say Layla, not that I hate her or anything but just too much and during the 1st season I grew very fond of the other girls. Trix I would keep I love them And Hero's would be Nabu

Posted by: MusicalStella Apr 30 2007, 11:27 PM

The Cloud Tower teachers. I like the Winx and the Trix too much, and Mirta and Lucy make an interesting backstory. You can't kick Nabu out yet though! We don't even know the poor guy yet!

Posted by: Boo May 1 2007, 12:25 AM

I would kick Layla off.. out of the trix I'd say Stormy, and I don't know out of the guys...

Posted by: Abby May 1 2007, 8:38 PM

I would kick off layla, i like her but not as much as everyone else, and nabu isn't a specialist though so I don't know but I would probably kick him off too. stormy out of the trix, she is kinda annoying

Posted by: 99RedBalloons May 1 2007, 10:20 PM

There seems to be a growing majority around here.

Posted by: Boo May 3 2007, 12:37 PM

I noticed that too o_O

Posted by: 99RedBalloons May 3 2007, 12:49 PM

I think I would evict Nabu not just because he hasn't really done anything yet, or even because he's not a specialist, but because I think he destroys the only good part of Aisha's character. Literally, the only purpose he serves is to give her a boyfriend, despite the fact that she claims to be so independent.

Posted by: May May 5 2007, 2:47 AM

Out of the specialists I would remove Helia, out of the fairies I'd remove Layla. Helia is soo dull, forgive me Boo but Timmy and Flora would be way better.

Posted by: P-girl May 5 2007, 8:37 AM

Out of the fairies: Layla (She just doesn't.... add anything, in my opinion)
Out of the specialists: Helia (Sorry, a cute face won't help if you don't show it that often.)
Out of the Witches: Icy (I just don't like her, period. Stormy's my fave witch)

Posted by: Harley May 9 2007, 4:45 AM

Fairies : Tecna, something about her (sorry Tecna fans!)
Specialist : Timmy, hmm... don't know why either (Helia, how can people evict him!)
Witches : Icy

Posted by: Selena May 9 2007, 5:19 AM

Thats what is so appling about Layla. She is a tomboy and offers a diffrent role model.
So i am going to have to agree with you.
"It's time to go...Nabu"

Posted by: 99RedBalloons May 9 2007, 11:43 AM

Yeah, and if he hasn't shown up by now (or...he has, but he hasn't done anything), then how critical could he really be to the plot? I mean, really.

Posted by: Boo May 13 2007, 4:09 AM

He will just stand in the background and look pretty

Posted by: mightymarty2 May 19 2007, 10:23 AM

Fairy: Murta (if she is one no idea anymore)-no one really
Hero: Nabu-ruins Laylas best personality from what I have heard
Witch: Darcy- adds nothing to trix
Overall it would be Mabu

Posted by: fullmoon May 20 2007, 8:40 PM

I never saw Nabu before. I think all the fairies are needed actually. It wouldn't be nice to actually kill one of the main characters though it would also be good since it'll add a good twist and winx club needs one.

Posted by: PrettyFlora May 21 2007, 6:49 PM

I'd kick off:

Winx: Layla ( I dont know, things constantly happen on her planet and im getting kind of sick of it, also used to the other ppl in the gang)
Trix: Stormy ( Hate her, hate her, hate her. Not only does she have a bad hair day everyday(lol), she also is kind of a nuisence)
Specialists: Im going to have to say... Helia (too quite for my liking)

Posted by: jenn May 23 2007, 7:02 AM

if I have to,
winx:layla(actually if bloom wasn't the main character and everything revolving her,I would evict her)
specialists:Nabu(basically he didn't do anything at all and his plaited hair is annoying me for some reason,he looks like those chinese warriors in the olden days)
witches:stormy(the sight of her just irks me.yup PrettyFlora,she does have a bad hair day everyday and not to mention a bad temper)

Posted by: SolarfireWinx May 28 2007, 3:27 AM

For me It'd be

Fairy: Layla/ Aisha -- It took me awhile to get to like her. Actually I take that back, It took me most of season two to like her. XD ((sorry layla fans.))
Specialist: Nabu
Witch: Stormy ((She's really annoying.))

Posted by: Another Morning May 28 2007, 4:10 AM

*very late, but oh well*

Fairy: Layla. I just never got used to her. Even now, I have to correct myself, because I always think there is only five Winx girls.
Specialists: I guess I'll have to say Nabu. I like all the others, and Nabu hasn't even shown up yet, so he can't be terribly important. >___>
Witches: Oh, but I like all of them. D: I guess if I had to choose, it would be...Darcy. But I don't want any of them to leave.

I know it would kind of mess up the whole plot for season three, but I would really love to get rid of Baltor. I have no idea why he annoys he so much, but he does. Oh, he does. I know I've said this at least twice, and people might be getting tired of it, but I really want to see somebody backhand him. And then he dies or something and goes away forever. o____o

Posted by: Boo Jun 3 2007, 11:51 PM

I liked it better when there were just 5 winx girls...

Posted by: Veronica Jun 8 2007, 3:23 PM

If i'd need to kick people off...

Fairy: Layla.
I think Layla kinda shattered the friendship of Tecna and Musa. In season 1 they were best buddies but Layla kinda 'stole' Musa from Tecna. Now Tecna is like never with Musa. And Layla is annoying: they give her more screen time than Musa, Flora and Tecna even though she came later! Layla is kinda too... odd. I guess they added her just to make winx more popular and there would be atleast one black girl that it would not seem racistic... Layla could just go because she has to control her realm...

Specialist: Nabu.
She destroys Layla's tomboy personality, it is annoying that everyone has a boyfriend. He has awful hair and it's a forced marriage anyway...

Trix: Darcy.
I kinda never got used to her. Icy has been always my favorite and even my favorite character in the beginning, i'd like run around the house if she'd leave. And Stormy can't leave: I'd miss her funny Finnish quotes! And her funny voice.

Posted by: Meru Jun 8 2007, 3:44 PM

I agree with getting rid of Layla. She is not much help, and she is kind of annoying.
And as for the guys; it would haveto be Nabu, even though I've yet to actually see an episode with him in it. He is just there to be a boyfriend for Layla. It kind of annoys me that all the winx go out with the group of specialists they are friends with.

as for the Trix, I don't think I really want any of them to leave. Sure Stormy's 4kids voice is annoying but I don't mind the character

I want to get rid of Mindy the most I think. Even though shes only in like one episode a season... and not even in season 3 to my knowledge.... shes annoying, stuck up and I would have punched her in her face if I were Bloom. That and I would have showed off to her my magic powers who would believe her if she tried to tell? >: D

Posted by: Musa : The Rockstar Jun 10 2007, 12:18 PM

[quote name='Selena' date='May 9 2007, 09:19 AM' post='13194']
Thats what is so appling about Layla. She is a tomboy and offers a diffrent role model.
So i am going to have to agree with you.
"It's time to go...Nabu"
[/qO]
I think....
Out of Winx : No one ( oh , come on , Layla & Tecna are good hip girls!!!)
Out of Specialists : Sky & Nabu ( I hate Sky)
Out of Witches : No one

Hope u guys agree.

Posted by: Ranma Jun 17 2007, 11:42 PM

Why do you hate Sky? I mean, seriously. Anyone that can put up with Bloom like the way he does is okay in my book.

I'd Vote off...BLOOM! Ha, I'm the first to say it! I know you're all thinking it!

Just kidding. Probaly Layla.

Out of the specialists: I like Helia the least (When I first came here I hated him, but I kind of like him now.) Everyone has been voting Nabu, but I like him from what I've seen of him ^_^

Witches: Stormy. Bad hair every day (lol), and her voice actress really annoys me. Her voice is like nails on a chalk board.

Side Characters: I'd have to say guy crossing the street B or random specialist C...They bug me.

Teacher...I'd get rid of Saladin...He doesn't really...do ... anything...

If I could add anything (I know I'm going out of control...I just drank a monster energy drink...)

Pet: Pipe Fox.
Reason: Isn't that the cutest thing you've ever seen? I want one.

Little form: http://youtube.com/watch?v=jtITP0wg4M4
Big form: http://youtube.com/watch?v=du7vYQs-kc0

I want one I want one I want one I want one!

Posted by: *Stella* Jun 18 2007, 10:57 AM

xD wel after i watched the new episode with nabu i have to say i dont wanna evict him^^ i like him

so i think its helia.. even if flora has no one to love then...

Posted by: mightymarty2 Jun 19 2007, 7:18 PM

I think Nabu should be evicted as soon as he and Layla start going out as he robs her of her independence from what I have heard but untill then I think it is a really interesting sub plot.

Posted by: Connie Jun 19 2007, 10:33 PM

Now that I've seen him, he isnt that bad and Layla was being a really spoil brat about what she said to him..poor thing

Posted by: winxclub-joy Jul 1 2007, 7:05 AM

I will kick off:
winx fairies: None of them (Come on, I like all of them)
Specialists: Sky & Helia ( cause Helia did not always show up in the show, for what the animators created him? Sky it's because I hate to see him, he annoys me)
Witch: None (If one of them is out, will the be trix again?)
Other characters: Mandy, cause she is super super annoying!

Posted by: Boo Jul 1 2007, 5:01 PM

*shudders* I don't like Nabu at all. Just his personality is really annoying, quote, "Looks like I got here just in time to see the show-down!" (between the witches & Baltor and the Winx). I find that to be kind of rude. I just don't like him, he gives me the impression of a stalker.

I totally agree with you! I saw a video where Layla was even in Tecna's room talking to Musa about Riven. That scene kind of obviously shows that she pushed Tecna and Musa's friendship away. Heres the screen:

Posted by: mightymarty2 Jul 3 2007, 6:20 PM

Aggreed. Musa and Techna worked well together.

Posted by: Smurfje Aug 8 2007, 8:05 PM

I am going to agree with you guys with kicking Layla out. I don't exactly hate her, but dang, she stole Musa's role! o_O In season 1, Musa was the most tomboy of all the Winx Club members, and I liked her that way. When Layla came she just took that tomboyish thing from Musa away and drew all the attention to herself o_O Or am I being mean now? ^^

For the specialist I'd say also Nebu. That guy is reaaaaaaaaaaaallly, reealllly reaaaaaally (three days later) reaaaaalllly annoying! He doesn't have a personality at all, it's like mightymarty2 said, he robbed Layla's independence.

Pixie: I guess Lokette...but I can't explain why ^^ I just like her the least ^^

Posted by: P-girl Aug 9 2007, 10:07 AM

Yes on Layla, yes on Lockette, but what makes you think Nabu doesn't have a personality? If someone lacks personality it's Helia. (Sorry Helia fans, but hey, I'm starting to become a Nabu-fan, and he's getting the brunt of the attack here.) If I didn't know more about this Realm, I'd say Helia was an elf. (The non-personality elves from most Fantasy-novels, not the über-cute Winx-club elf Palladium.)

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Aug 9 2007, 6:39 PM

i totally agree with you surfje. musa was the tomyboyish and the dancer until layla came. so i would kick out layla. i would kick out bloom but if no bloom no winx club its that simple.
and i would kick out nabu and sky. i don't like sky cause he seem like a mommy boy. sorry for all those sky fan out there.
and for the witches i say none cause i sort of like the witches. but i hate darcy the most.

Posted by: Palladium fangirl Aug 11 2007, 12:25 AM

Ok I'm going to be the first to say this but Griselda all she does is punish people yeesh what is she my mother

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Aug 11 2007, 7:30 PM

i almost forgot about her. but wait she doesn't punish the fairy alot like she use to. but for some strange reason i like her. don't know why.

Posted by: Smurfje Aug 11 2007, 9:54 PM

Could you please explain me what kind of a personality Nebu has? Because I can't see it o_O



Ah, thanks for agreeing with me While I think about it, I think I dislike Sky more than I dislike Nabu. Sky is like...I don't know, some error or so. I think the Winx designers wanted to create the perfect boyfriend, but they created Sky instead! o_O

Posted by: Riliana Aug 12 2007, 7:32 AM

Well I would evict layla off the bat i never really liked her. She just sort of barged in is way i see it. I liked when there was only 5 fairies.

Now I have no knowledge much of Nabu, so i want to get to know him a little bit more. But I really am not likeing Sky at the moment, the way he deals with things its like he thinks hes god. I just cant stand him . Now Helia needs to open up more. He had the guts to stand up to Riven which was good but still more wold be better.

I actually like the witches, Diaspro and Chimera for the fact they help put the plot into the series. So with out them its just another soap opera lol.

Now we havent even seen Avalon in Season 3 whats up with that???

Posted by: Palladium fangirl Aug 13 2007, 8:21 PM

Maybe because she can be kind too

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Aug 13 2007, 9:23 PM

i guess so.

Posted by: Palladium fangirl Aug 14 2007, 12:16 AM

But I've noticed she has not punished people in a while it's wierd

Posted by: mimi_x3 Aug 14 2007, 7:03 AM

i would envict layla sorry she just doenst fit in and i dont lik her that much no reason why

as for heros ; eh if ur gonna take the girl den might as well let her have her prince so nabu

and pixie NONE I LOVE EM TOO MUCH!!! lol

Posted by: winxclub101 Aug 14 2007, 2:49 PM

fairy: no one
specialist: riven
witches: darcy
im saying no fairy because season 2 and 3 wouldnt really fit without layla

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Aug 14 2007, 8:52 PM

why do you want to kick riven out. hes my favorite out of the specialist. but i agree with taking out darcy. i don't like her. but i would like her to stay as well. don't know why.

Posted by: melgirl1778 Aug 14 2007, 9:50 PM

faries - layla, its like she doesnt belong, though i love her outfit!

specialists - riven, i jut dont like him...

Witces - darcy. just dont like her either

villans - baltor. i didnt like season 2 very much.

Posted by: P-girl Aug 15 2007, 5:27 PM

But Baltor's from Season 3, you meant Darkar? Or maybe you meant Baltor, but you meant to say that you didn't like season 3..... I'll shut up now.

Posted by: winxclub101 Aug 16 2007, 3:30 PM

i also said that because winx club woldnt be winx club to me with any fairy evicted

Posted by: winxclub-joy Aug 19 2007, 9:03 AM

YES YES someone finally said that Sky was a mommy boy! lol XD
I also having the same opinion with you about sky too. But I don't think I will kick out the winx girls, it's like come on they are a team~!

As for nabu, I think I will kick out him cuz like some PPLs here said, he took Layla's independence.

I will also kick out Heila cuz the animators don't focused on him, besides his name, I don't even know his personality.

And that girl called Mandy/Mitzi, she's such an super annoying girl! If I'm Bloom I will surely turns her intoa pig.

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Aug 20 2007, 6:24 PM

thanks winxclub-joy for agreeing with me. i like helia but they really don't focuse on him alot. you are right. and i barely see him in any of the episode. how does flora handle it, him not ever being there with her.

Posted by: winxclub-joy Aug 24 2007, 11:15 AM

So do I =X

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Aug 24 2007, 7:29 PM

i guess we'll never know........

Posted by: Griselda Oct 4 2007, 8:45 PM

There's a lot of Layla hate here. To me, that's sad.

Anyway, I would evict Codatorta. He's Saladin's assistant. Contrary to what people think, he is not a male version of Griselda- and he doesn't try hard to impress everyone because he has no magic, either. He's just a man with all muscles and no brains that lives for showing off his masculinity.

"I'M CODATORTA I HAVE MANLY ABS OF MANLINESS WATCH ME POUNDS STUFF AND TEACH BOYS HOW TO POUND STUFF HEY BOYS GET OVER HERE!"

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Oct 4 2007, 9:06 PM

i think you are the first person to evict Codatorta. i don't like him neither. he wasn't shown so much in season 2 and barely show at all in season 3.

Posted by: AnnieBelle Oct 28 2007, 8:51 PM

Hm...eviction notices?

Winx: No one, for now...
Specialists: Yeah, totally Nabu/Ophir.
Pixies: does Glim DO anything besides be cute?
Teachers: I agree, Griselda, I'd evict Codatorta. He's just there for...um...Yeah, I really don't have any idea. The only time I've ever actually paid attention to him is when I played the 4kids episode 'Party Monster' backwards on my DVD player and made him just comment on his muscles the whole time...

And yeah, Griselda's been a little lenient lately.

Posted by: Boo Oct 29 2007, 1:03 AM

I never thought about Cordatorta. I never really hated him, but never really liked him. He was just kind of...there. He didn't really do anything so he didn't bug me as much as others.

aww, I think Glim is cute, maybe it's because she doesn't talk, (sometimes the pixies' voices bug me....)

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Oct 29 2007, 8:37 PM

i don't like or like glim. i guess they wanted to put another baby pixie so piff won't be the only one.

Posted by: AnnieBelle Oct 29 2007, 8:44 PM

Another question: What's up with the baby pixies? I mean, in that one episode where Flora got her Charmix, we SAW pixies being born, and the ones that came out didn't look anything like babies (to me).

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Oct 29 2007, 8:59 PM

i don't know. its just something they did.

Posted by: Boo Oct 29 2007, 11:17 PM

*shrugs* Maybe some come out like babies and others don't. I dunno. I suppose that the creators didn't carry the baby pixie thing in their minds when they made the scene...

Posted by: winxclub-joy Oct 30 2007, 5:12 AM

I should say the creators are plain lazy, they make too much mistakes including in the movie. Seriously I don't believe that winx movie worth million of euro dollars............

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Oct 30 2007, 7:08 PM

will you can't blame them.so you know how much work you have to do for one episode. and the movie. so much and it tired them out. the poor workers. give them a break. everyone makes mistake. sorry if i sould mean but nobody can be perfect. plus sometimes i think they put some mistakes to see if the audience pays attention to the show.

sorry my spelling was wrong. i meant sound not sould.

Posted by: winxclub-joy Oct 31 2007, 3:45 AM

I know in this world nobody's perfect. But being a animator can't make any mistakes, my friend said that being an animator all you need is to create a perfect animations. If you make an mistake, the cartoons will not be perfect and a lot of us won't like it right? But if an 3D animator makes a mistake, I don't know what to say I'm totally speechless

Posted by: P-girl Oct 31 2007, 7:41 AM

Meh, I don't burn off cartoons and/or their animators because of animation errors if the rest is done really well. If I would, my favorite cartoon ever, Transformers, would be in big trouble. (Inconstistent scale is their forte, for over twenty years now.)

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Oct 31 2007, 8:21 PM

well yea. i wouldn't like a mistake in the movie either.

Posted by: P-girl Oct 31 2007, 8:28 PM

A long as you're not gonna nitpick like 'Oh, that one strand of hair is colored wrong.'

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Oct 31 2007, 8:41 PM

lol.

Posted by: Boo Nov 1 2007, 8:24 PM

I don't blame the animators, they have a hard job. Think of some of the cartoons on Cartoon Network, look at the simplicity of the cartoons there (many of them.) Winx is a very detailed cartoon, so a couple mistakes is almost expected. Every so often, they forget to add a line or two, I don't find it to be all that horrible. I give them credit for all the hard work they put into it.

Posted by: P-girl Nov 1 2007, 8:28 PM

Besides, I remember the eighties (Good times, good times.). With those shows you started to get worries when there weren't animation errors.

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Nov 1 2007, 8:54 PM

your right. winx club has such beautiful designs.

P-girl. lol.

Posted by: Veronica Nov 6 2007, 1:36 PM

I'd kickie out that little guy called Sky. xD Oh gosh we do hate him

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Nov 6 2007, 6:50 PM

it seems like it.

Posted by: winxclub-joy Nov 7 2007, 2:32 AM

True most of all Magixclub members hate him lolz

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Nov 7 2007, 9:14 PM

but one the 4kids winx club. almost all of them love him.

Posted by: P-girl Nov 7 2007, 9:19 PM

I got the feeling the members of the 4Kids forum are of a younger demographic then us.

Posted by: musaenchantixthebest Nov 7 2007, 9:59 PM

yea. i agree with you.

Posted by: WinxFairyAlianne Apr 1 2008, 8:46 PM

I would get rid of out of specialists helia! He is so annoying!
I would not get rid of any of the fairys!
The trix I would get rid of darcy! Her powers wierd!

Posted by: Unica-Musa Apr 4 2008, 2:01 PM

Yeah...That's true Helia is soooooooooo stupid...

Posted by: WinxFairyAlianne Apr 4 2008, 3:51 PM

Yay Finally someone aggrees

Posted by: Unica-Musa Apr 4 2008, 5:02 PM

It's no wonders that I agree because Helia is acting like a idiot

Posted by: terriordx32 Apr 4 2008, 7:31 PM

musa's voice annoy me

Posted by: WinxFairyAlianne Apr 4 2008, 9:03 PM

me 2!

Posted by: Unica-Musa Apr 5 2008, 7:23 AM

In 4kids version????

Posted by: WinxFairyAlianne Apr 5 2008, 2:50 PM

In both!

Posted by: Zhanneel Apr 7 2008, 1:05 PM

Back to Helia....there was something about him I didn't like at the beginning. When he rescued Flora from the rampant dragon at Red Fountain I was like "ooh, he's a nice guy afterall and not weird, creepy, and introverted" lol. But then after he saved Flora and he knew she was safe he basically let the dragon loose on the other characters and walked away. Okay, fine, he saved Flora once. What would he ever do if the dragon he let loose attacked Flora again XD. And he would have been gone, drinking coffee at starbucks, brainstorming poetry not to care =P. I think his indifference to the other characters is harming is image. So i'd agree to say bye bye to Helia, though I guess he is better now that he is a Specialist.

As for fairy, I would let go of Layla/Aisha. Again, it's the attitude thing. I love tomboys and funny girls, but she was too rude to the boyfriends at the beginning. Her over confidence at anything manly is very annoying. I think if she acted a bit more natural and wouldn't show up the boys so much I'd take back what I said. Overall, she's not that bad. I think the 4kids voice though is affecting me more than her actual personality. They make her sound a bit too ghetto, but maybe that's just me.

Posted by: Boo Apr 17 2008, 10:43 PM

I actually like her voice in the 4kids version; it seems to fit well. I do agree about the showing up the boys. It's just too much really... ok, we get that she's a tomboy and all, we don't need to be constantly reminded. I would like her a lot more if she was still independent. I thought it was really neat that they made an independent character and didn't just bring her in as a newbie and stick her with a guy to make a pretty couple. It was so much more interesting to have a single character, since all of the rest of the girls were dating. But alas, they bring Nabu/Ophir, and Layla ends up with a guy. Oh how great.

Posted by: terriordx32 Apr 18 2008, 12:47 AM

i would let techna go, she annoys me to, and she only the brains
out of the boys to me sky or brandon can go
and i dont really care bout the pixies or w/e there called

Posted by: Zhanneel Apr 18 2008, 3:21 AM

Even though I would never evict her, I can see why some would want to evict Tecna. But I blame it on the writers and not so much her actual personality. I think I connect most with Tecna, as she is responsible and mature, and maybe being older makes me love those parts of her character the most. Also her intelligence, since I love knowledge and learning. But as for younger kids, I can see how they might never relate to someone who's a little too far advanced for them. Also, and this irks me quite a bit, the dialogue the writer's give her is so empty. They overuse words like "logical" and "by my calculations." Really, no one talks like that. It annoys the crud out of me. I just ignore those instances where the writer's stereotype her character and focus on the funny, innocent, or cute things she does. And lastly, I think people assume she is a superior snob (once again, that is completely the fault of the writers and staff who chose her 4Kids voice). They picked a high British voice, which if I could change, I might have her sound more Australian to tone down the "snob-like" quality of her voice. Or, keep the British voice, but change her dialogue to make it flow more with the rest of the Winx Club girls. Okay, I'm done bashing my favorite character =P.




I think I'm the only one who doesn't like her voice...or it could be that I associate her voice with her rudeness? Possibly... But I agree, she would have been better off being independent, if only she could have become more friendly and clashed less with the boys. I don't even know what the point of Nabu is, since we've barely seen him and is almost non-existent in the movie. If only we could help direct the story...blah.

Posted by: WinxFairyAlianne Apr 23 2008, 6:54 AM

Her voice annoys me too!

Posted by: W.I.N.X Apr 24 2008, 10:44 AM

Depends on the version. It's weird but I hate Bloom in the 4kids dub but in the Rai she's my favorite. She doesn't seem so annoying in that one. Now I'm actually a firm believer in the Rai dub so...DAMN 4KIDS TV!
Anyway

Fairy: 4kids:Bloom Rai: No one
Hero: Nabu totally. I liked Layla being independant!
Pixie: All of them. In every version. They're such a waste of space! We could've looked into Tecna's past rather than that stupid pixie episode.
Witch: None anywhere.

Just my 2 cents.

Posted by: Dilaraphoenix Jul 21 2008, 8:45 AM

I'd kick off Layla if i had to kick someone from all characters. Cause i hate her poses and she usually has a sad face.

Posted by: humbu111 Jul 22 2008, 11:04 PM

DEFINATELY HELIA (sorry, but Flora deserves WAY better)

Posted by: Hirondelle Jul 26 2008, 7:25 AM

Haha, personally I find Helia suits Flora great, just the writers screwed him up. (But then again aren't they to blame for everything?) He's romantic, sensitive and isn't so typical like the others; I was caught off guard though when he let the dragon go just to save Flora only. Then ran off. He could've at least ran off to make another dramatic enterance or something. Jeez.
I would never get rid of Helia, mainly for the fact he's the one that looks the best, next to Brandon.

I don't think I'd throw out a fairy...Aisha's apparently a popular one in this thread, but I don't even know why I favor her somehow. I forgot the reason, but she can stay I think. I don't think much about sports and her "feminist" attitude (I haaaaate those) but being independent would definitely add some variety. But it's not like she has a choice to have Nabu anyway...besides I like him, I find him pretty humorous and makes for a pretty good fiancee.

The hero I'd throw out...definitely <i>Sky.</i> Ehck. I don't like his design and I can't stand scenes with him in it. He's not bad, but he needs a frickin' haircut. I don't care how he was designed, he is not a pretty boy. Besides, for some reason, I can see Bloom easily with another guy. Probably a guy who's more mature and has it together. Then again, I don't really like Blond boys to begin with, I feel like I'm being biased anyway I have to go with the 4kids adaptations. He might not be so bad and Aisha might be worse.

Between Icy and Stormy, I don't know which one I'd love to kick out more. But after seeing the RAI dub, I found Icy's voice to be a bit refreshing than her "evil-doom-sounding" voice of her 4kids translation. It sounds pretty young and innocent strangely enough. That being said, I think I'd choose Stormy to toss out; I can't stand her attitude. Gets wayyy too mad wayyy too easily and that is one thing that has always been my pet peeve with people; real or fictional. It just doesn't make much sense at all. She needs to be smacked, I'm sorry.

Lastly, I'd get rid of the Pixie Zing. Sure, she has that cosplay charm, but I didn't find her all that cute of a character. Well, it's either her or Libby really, but I think I just don't like Libby's design.

Posted by: winxclub-joy Jul 26 2008, 7:29 AM

Humm, gotta update whom I wanted to kick off now!

Winx: Obviously no one, I still like them
Specialists: I don't kick out Nabu now, he's way to cool. I think I'll still vote that Sky should be kick out, and Bloom should get a new guy. I would like to see Bloom's cuter and greater stead, whoo~
Pixies: Nah, just get rid of their voice actors
Witches: Nah, none of them.


That's for an update

Posted by: P-girl Jul 26 2008, 7:31 AM

How 'bout the cute guy from the season 4 promotional folder? (I, for one, don't believe it's Helia.)

Posted by: Hirondelle Jul 26 2008, 5:51 PM

If that dude really turns out to be Helia, I might take back what I said about never evicting him. His fringe and the fact he's wearing pink doesn't fly well with me at alllllll. I totally forgot about that. <<; I sorta believe that it's him but I don't want to; I'm only convinced with the fact they don't introduce him or just his name on the flyer but they really don't have to..

Posted by: winxclub-joy Jul 27 2008, 2:57 AM

oh ya, but I'm praying that that is not helia

Posted by: PinkSugar Jul 27 2008, 6:15 PM

I think that if I could kick her out with no series reprocusions, I'd kick out Bloom. I get tired of Bloom always being the "it" factor (but that's what WinX is kind of about isn't it?) Following her, it would be Aisha/Layla. Yeah, I just... never liked her. Could never get rid of Stella- she's my favorite WinX girl.

Witches? Darcy. I love the trix as a whole group, but Darcy has just never add any flair for me. Icy is my favorite character in the series, so I could never get rid of her.

Specialists... Sky, no questions. Then Nabu. I love Helia. He's my favorite specialists. The fact he saved Flora and not the other girls gave him a bit of an extra quality for me. He was a pre-packaged hero like the others.

As for the pixies, I don't really like any of them except Amore and Tune.

Hmm, and for Villains, let's get rid of Valtor. I just never could get used to him in season 3.

Teachers, I couldn't care less. I have favorites, but I don't hate anyone. I think my favorites would be Palladium and Griffin, though. I'd kick Faragonda out if I had to get rid of one, but I'd prefer not to.

Posted by: Riiana Jul 30 2008, 2:42 PM

I don't know about you guys but I would love to have Stormy's hair. Of course I would actualyl ATTEMPT, even, to control it. Unlike Stormy..

Ah, heck with it.

I'd kick out...Bloom. (:

I adore Layla's hair.
As you've probably noticed, Im in love with curly hair. Dunno why, probably cause my hair is naturally straight/wavy. >.<

Posted by: Winxgirl66 Aug 1 2008, 10:36 PM

Nabu..

for the trix, i would say stormy.

Posted by: Music123 Aug 25 2008, 7:17 AM

I would kick out Layla, sorry to Layla fans but season 1 was ok without her.

Posted by: KLEB Oct 15 2008, 3:01 AM

Fairy-Layla, i love all of them! i do! But Layla is just not my fav!
Witch-Darcy-not big fan of her and Riven, it made everything so complicated!
Specialist-Nabu

Posted by: CaffinatedAngst Nov 4 2008, 7:10 PM

Chimera and Cassandra. Their both two-face characters and I can't stand people like that.

I could also get rid of Bloom. While she is one of my favorite characters, but she whine so much! She really doesn't have that much to whine about.

Posted by: Stella303 Nov 7 2008, 10:38 PM

If I had to get rid of a fairy I would have to say....Tecna sorry Tecna fans she's my least fav. For the trix, no hesitation, Stormy. A boy, I don't know...

Posted by: P-girl Nov 7 2008, 10:40 PM

Good, good.... what are your reasons? Don't mind me, I'm a person who likes to know reasons.

Posted by: romir Apr 11 2009, 9:18 PM

i don't really want to evict someone!
but if it musti think i'm going for grizeldaXD
no sorry i think for one of the trix!!

Posted by: Tom273 Apr 11 2009, 9:37 PM

i would evict Griselda... i can't think of anyone else she is annoying... almost all the winx characters are cool lol i think even Amaryl is cool.

Posted by: romir Apr 12 2009, 3:39 PM

yeah tha's right!

Posted by: humbu111 Apr 12 2009, 4:26 PM

[noguests]I'd evict Helia. I've already hated on him enough though in other topic so I wont re-state why. [/noguests]

Posted by: Dark_Side_Master Apr 15 2009, 6:52 PM

i'd evict layla, it's just like the all of cartoons, serials and everything like that is based on the 1 season, and when you adding completly new characters in it its main characters company, like we have here, its's a kind of frightening. im not talking about villians ofcourse, making them new is a part of every show.
that words making me say that evicting helia from the specialists is most logical, but i'm really impressed with him. so there are no one to kick.
at last trix. its just immpossible to kick someone frome their company after so much events happened to them, so everyone of them are important for the show.

Posted by: fullmoon Apr 15 2009, 9:33 PM

I think that all the pixies should be evicted. I think they probably are since there are no signs that they appear in season 4. MWAHAHA!

Posted by: humbu111 Apr 15 2009, 10:01 PM

[noguests]I'd rather have the pixies rather than those new pets *gag me* [/noguests]

Posted by: Tom273 Apr 17 2009, 7:57 PM

i would also have the pixies rather than the new pets (don't hit me XD)

Posted by: IcyLover121 Apr 18 2009, 12:54 AM

omg, I'D EVICT BLOOM!!!! not trying to be mean to any Bloom fans or anything, but i really don't like her, so yeah, i would definitely take her away. Then again, if they took Layla away, then it would be like in season 1 again, and season 1 is my all-time fave. So one of them for the Winx. For the Trix, i wouldn't want any of them removed. If i absolutely HAD to chose, i'd say Stormy, but i like them all, so yeah. Specialist would be both Ophere and Helia...they're just add-ons. But Flora DOES need to have a boyfriend cuz of the enchantix and everything, so i say Ophere.

omg, I'D EVICT BLOOM!!!! not trying to be mean to any Bloom fans or anything, but i really don't like her, so yeah, i would definitely take her away. Then again, if they took Layla away, then it would be like in season 1 again, and season 1 is my all-time fave. So one of them for the Winx. For the Trix, i wouldn't want any of them removed. If i absolutely HAD to chose, i'd say Stormy, but i like them all, so yeah. Specialist would be both Ophere and Helia...they're just add-ons. But Flora DOES need to have a boyfriend cuz of the enchantix and everything, so i say Ophere.

Posted by: P-girl Apr 18 2009, 9:30 AM

So..... you basically want Winx club not to exist.

Sorry if it sounds crude, but this is one of the main reasons I think Bloom deserves at least some respect: Without her, the story wouldn't exist. No Stella being accidentally saved by her, no Trix finding the Dragonfire, no lost princess of Domino. Nothing.

Posted by: IcyLover121 Apr 18 2009, 2:45 PM

yeah it does sorta sound that way, but i know what u mean, that's why i said i'd change it to Layla (or Aisha or whatever her name is in some other version) Bloom's my least favorite character, but yeah, it wouldn't make sense fr her to have not been there the whole time.

Posted by: Dark_Side_Master Apr 18 2009, 6:32 PM

evecting that kind of characters in every show is impossible and just doesn't make sence. there is nothing even to talk about

Posted by: Anna Maria Apr 23 2009, 11:01 AM

I'd evict Layla. I don't know, I don't quite like her for an unspecific reason. Perhaps it is because I was used to five Winx and adding more characters seems a little crazy. Apart from that, Layla has a face that makes me want to punch her.
I wouldn't evict anyone from the Specialists or the Trix though. Trix are already three, and I believe that Icy, Darcy and Stormy make a great trio. Specialists are good, too. They already have girlfriends from Winx and each couple is matching. I'm not sure about Nabu though, but oh well.

Posted by: IcyLover121 Apr 23 2009, 7:48 PM

agree 100%!!!!! i didn't like how they just added Layla for something to do! and then they added Nabu (or Ophere in the version i saw) for the same reason!

Posted by: P-girl Apr 23 2009, 7:52 PM

Nabu shows that not all boys have to be Specialists, and that not only girls and evil dudes can work magic. He's just as much as a vital part as Layla, Helia or everyone else. I know I added my share of 'evicted' characters to this list, but I've grown to love, or at least respect them and their roles in the series.

Posted by: bubamara Apr 23 2009, 8:06 PM

New pets? Do they count?
I know some of you like them, but I just really don't see the point in having them. They are worse than pixies (at least pixies were doing something, these are just "cute stuff", like nice background)

Posted by: P-girl Apr 23 2009, 8:10 PM

So..... You don't want the Winx to make a living? Nice.... (Face it, those pets are now their primary source of income. And if my speculations are correct, an important part of achieving their Believix.)

Posted by: bubamara Apr 23 2009, 8:14 PM

They give them, not sell. (At least I think, they say adoptare, isn't it supposed to mean adopt?)
And they can be waitresses, deliver parcels, it would be more fun

Posted by: P-girl Apr 23 2009, 8:16 PM

Nope, it's a pet STORE. I taught it was kind of obvious.

And while it would be more fun to have them as waitresses or delivery-girls, this is the job Iginio gave them.

Posted by: bubamara Apr 23 2009, 8:21 PM

I'm not sure. I thought as well, but than when I saw them giving them away over the internet, and bloom saying to faragonda adoptare, i started to wonder. Anyway, this is not the topic, sorry for the spam.
And I wouldn't evict fairies or boys, in fact, I would add more background characters, like Nova and Galatea... I miss them, since they made it feel that there is more in Alfea than winx club...

Posted by: P-girl Apr 23 2009, 8:22 PM

Same here, it's why I'm all for minor character love; it gives more depth to the world around the major characters, making it alive.

Posted by: Anna Maria Apr 24 2009, 8:37 PM

Who are Nova and Galatea?
Anyway, now that I'm thinking again (and got to know Layla better) I think she shouldn't be evicted.
So I don't evict anyone. Hm.

Posted by: P-girl Apr 24 2009, 8:39 PM

Nova was a girl from Solaria who kept Stella informed about the happenings there in Season 3.
Galatea is the Princess of Musa's kingdom. (No, Musa isn't royalty, 4Kids dubbed that in, because you can't be cool unless you're a princess [/sarcasm], she's the one that got her wings frozen and discarded by the Trix, before being saved by Musa, who gained her Enchantix for it.

Posted by: Anna Maria Apr 25 2009, 8:19 AM

Poor Galatea... Thanks P-Girl for the explanation!

Posted by: {§hani™} May 3 2009, 12:08 PM

well i dislike Bloom and Stella but i wouldnt 'evict' them.
maybe mitzy i hate her x-x

i have to say the couplings are cute but i hate how they all have someone!! its all little too clishe for me. i'd take out Nabu and Timmy and maybe Brandon but he's crucial so i dunno o-o i like helia and riven too much XD

Posted by: Bloomrocks1234 May 31 2009, 11:10 PM

i evict layla and nabu but i would never do that to piff too cute for pixie i would evict tune because she not really useful layla because she is like the last to come well roxy is but she cannot be evicted because then bloom would be main charater again nabu because without hime layla wouldn't act all girly in season 4

Posted by: P-girl May 31 2009, 11:12 PM

But without Nabu, Season 4 would have a SERIOUS lack of like-able and handsome guys on the good side.

Posted by: Boo Jun 1 2009, 12:19 AM

I would evict them as well, personally.
I would have liked to have seen the girls get real jobs versus selling magical creatures on Earth... I would think that it would have been more interesting that way... But I suppose that would be drifting away from their target demographic...

But, of course, they (Rainbow) must have felt compelled to add more cutesy characters to the show... Perhaps to make more money off of it? It seems to me that they're trying to attract the little ones who enjoy "Littlest Pet Shop" sorts of toys...
More money for them, less enjoyable season for older viewers like me.

Ah well...

Posted by: humbu111 Jun 1 2009, 12:21 AM

[noguests]I think maybe they added the pets to take the place of the pixies, since they're saving the pixies for Pop Pixies. [/noguests]

Posted by: sindain Jun 11 2009, 10:16 AM

Err, yeah. I'd evict Roxy.
Somehow, I think her character storyplot will be very similar to Blooms.
Plus, I don't like her. >.<

Posted by: P-girl Jun 11 2009, 11:10 AM

So...... you just want Season 4 not to happen. I know I made my claims of evicting characters, but I realised that without some characters, there wouldn't be storylines, Seasons or even the entirety of Winx Club.

Posted by: winxclubrox23 Jun 13 2009, 10:37 PM

I'm debating between Helia, and Flora. I'd probably evict Helia for the reasons I've often stated and are known to most of the forum.

Posted by: humbu111 Jun 13 2009, 10:40 PM

Why evict Flora?

Posted by: winxclubrox23 Jun 13 2009, 10:41 PM

Because I absolutely can't stand her.

Posted by: humbu111 Jun 13 2009, 10:43 PM

Oh wow I never knew that. She's my second fave, I think she's awesome. All nice until you mess with her, then you go down.

Posted by: winxclubrox23 Jun 13 2009, 10:46 PM

Oh wow! I can't believe you didn't know that I hate her! Wow...well I guess I haven't expressed it as much as Helia.

Posted by: humbu111 Jun 13 2009, 10:48 PM

Yes you havent lol. But what about her do you hate exactly?

Posted by: winxclubrox23 Jun 13 2009, 10:52 PM

Everything. She just too....goody-goody for me I guess.

What I would do is kick out Flora and then put in Galatea. I really liked her and think she'd be a better addition to the Winx Club than Flora.

Posted by: humbu111 Jun 13 2009, 10:53 PM

Galatea is cool, but she's too similar to Musa power wise and Bloom personality wise. Whereas Flora has something unique to offer.

Posted by: winxclubrox23 Jun 13 2009, 10:57 PM

Galatea like Bloom? I didn't think so at all. I thought she was more so like Musa. Ooh, or Nova. We could replace Flora with Nova...OR DIASPRO! YES! I love Diaspro! She one of my all time fave minor characters.

Posted by: humbu111 Jun 13 2009, 11:03 PM

I dunno something about her made me think Bloom. She had this sorta leader-like quality about her, like taking her own authority. And when she was with the witches, it reminded me of Bloom with them when she was powerless.

ABout Nova, well that would be okay but I dont think she has enough personality to be a big character. She's sorta like they just needed a character to bring Stella news, so they quickly put someone together. Looks wise too, she looks pretty boring.

Haha replace her with Diaspro xD. Her and Diaspro are like polar opposites =P. I know you werent serious about it, but I dont think they'd accomplish anything with Diaspro on their side, they'd just argue the whole time. Plus Diaspro would be all I dont wanna go on any missions, I'm royalty.

Posted by: winxclubrox23 Jun 13 2009, 11:06 PM

Lol

'You aren't the only Princess here Stella'

That totally reminded me of that. Sheesh...that was one sloppy cover-up. Musa's princess status I mean.

Posted by: humbu111 Jun 13 2009, 11:08 PM

Sorry, I dont get it.

Posted by: winxclubrox23 Jun 13 2009, 11:14 PM

Okay, so...

In season 1, 4kids said that Musa was a princess. But then, in season 2 we find out that she actually wasn't. So to cover up their mistake, they said that Musa's dad was a dis-owned prince.

When you said that Diaspro would be all 'No! I'm royalty' it reminded me of Musa's quote from season 1 when Stella was complaining about work, and Musa said that she wasn't the only princess there. By that she was referring to herself, but she's actually not a princess.

If that made any sense...Lol

Posted by: humbu111 Jun 13 2009, 11:20 PM

Ohh, I get it now lol. Yes I remember xD

Posted by: winxclubrox23 Jun 13 2009, 11:26 PM

Oh plus, in the Day of The Rose, when Musa's up on that balcony she says:

'I remember you used to tell me about this place mom. You said it was your favourite spot when you went to Alfea. Where Dad first kissed you.'

But THEN

In season 2, Musa's parents first kissed beside a freaking fridge. Last time I checked, that's not a balcony.

In my opinion, 4kids had to change Musa's past quite a bit season to season.

Posted by: humbu111 Jun 13 2009, 11:30 PM

Lol wow Teagan, you should change that thing in your siggy to "Riven And Musa Expert" taking out the 'self proclaimed' and adding 'And Musa' cause its true. Wow lol you sure are good at noticing things like that XD

Posted by: winxclubrox23 Jun 13 2009, 11:33 PM

Haha nah....I just really like Winx Club... plus like I've said before, I remember the stuff that I'm never going to use again. Like really? When am I ever going to need to know Musa's past screw up?

Posted by: maeflower Oct 25 2012, 10:58 PM

Yeah, I TOTALLY know what you mean, winxclubrox23; the sucky part about liking Winx Club (for me at least), is that it's useful neither academically nor socially. I'm pretty sure my friends would send me to the corner if I confessed to liking it.

As for the topic at hand, I am OBSSESSED with Riven (to an actually frightening degree, given that this is a kid's cartoon -- it's just so nice to have a Specialist that's not meant to be a cardboard cut-out behind the fairies; plus I'm a massive sucker for tortured pasts) and LOVE Musa (music is my life, and I feel like I can relate to her way more than any other female on the show). Basically, as long as you don't get rid of them, boot whoever you want -- though I'd be grateful if you considered Aisha/Layla. It's like they added her because the producers were worried that the show wasn't blatantly feminist enough; don't worry. It totally is.

I mean, seriously, we got the point.

Rant: over.

Posted by: willkz Jan 4 2014, 7:46 PM

the trix from season 3 and 5